
With the recent announcement that Paramount will only release HD-DVD's from now on, I decided to share my thoughts on the current HD format war. For those of you who have no idea what the deal is, there is a technology war going on over which format will replace the DVD players in your homes. The two formats in question are Blu-Ray, and HD-DVD.
With the price of High Definition televisions falling like crazy, lots of people are beginning to invest in nice flat screen TV's. What most people don't realize, is that once you get one of these nice screens, all your DVD's, and local cable television will suddenly look bad, blurry, grainy, and fuzzy. This is because currently normal televisions display 525 lines of resolution. These new HD televisions, can display up to 1080 lines of progressive scanning. Thats more than double in vertical resolution. So the TV ends up scaling the 500 lines of normal DVD's and televisions, to 1080. Stretching the image to fill the screen. That can cause the image to look bad because half of the lines are not being used, or doubled.
So once you notice this, you realize that you will need to get HD cable, just so the images looks nice. So naturally you will want your movies to look nice, so you will need a HD disc player for your movies.
The problem is that all the movie studios are not in the same boat, some are committed to deliver movies in Sony's Blu-ray format, and some are on the other side with Toshiba's HD-DVD format. Technically speaking, both formats are HD, but the difference basically boils down to the amount of data that can be stored in the discs. Currently, Blu-ray discs can hold up to 50 gigs. To make a comparison, normal DVD's can hold 9 gigs max. HD-DVD's can hold 30 gigs. So Blu-ray can hold more footage than HD-DVD's, but its more expensive because its newer technology, and thats the hole debate now.
Some people want the extra space to add more content to the disks, such as extra behind the scenes footage and featurettes, others don't want to pay the extra for newer technology.
Studios that are committed to Blu-ray are: Sony Pictures, MGM, Disney, Pixar, 20th Century Fox, and Lion's Gate.
Studios under the HD-DVD camp are: Universal, Paramount, and the Weinstein Co.
Warner is in both camps and currently makes both Blu-ray and HD-DVD's.
Personally, I feel that some competition between the two is good because it will drive the price tag down. But it also has a counter effect because now people are afraid to buy either because they don't want to buy the one that will lose out in the end. I know some people who spent tons on Betamax only to have it become obsolete to VHS. I also remember that when DVD's came out, there was another format called DIVIX, that lost out in the battle, so if you bought one you lost all your money.
So who will win, its too early to tell, but I have noticed that most stores I go to have bigger Blu-ray displays and some only have blu-ray players. Blockbuster now only will carry Blu-ray, and from my experience more people have heard of Blu-ray than HD-DVD. But then again, Paramount just announced that it will only release its films on HD-DVD, so we will have to see what happens now as the pot gets stirred because Paramount has lots of great films that people will want. Paramount did say that Speilberg's films are not bound to HD-DVD and will probably come out on Blu-ray. That's interesting...